EP#351 | GUEST | Judaism, Zionism & Genocide: A Raw Conversation with Jonathan Randall

Aug 1

📄 Episode Overview

In Episode #351, Ray Doustdar sits down with Jewish-American comedian and activist Jonathan Randall for one of the most heartfelt and courageous conversations the DSD podcast has hosted. Randall, a vocal advocate for Palestinian human rights, breaks down the crucial distinction between Judaism and Zionism while sharing deeply personal stories about how his activism has cost him relationships, gigs, and family connections. This powerful episode offers an unfiltered look at identity, integrity, and the courage to speak out in the face of injustice.

🎯 Key Takeaways

• Judaism and Zionism are not synonymous—Zionism is a political ideology, not a religious tenet
• Speaking up for Palestinian human rights comes at a personal cost, especially for Jewish voices
• Silence and fear enable oppression; courage and dialogue open pathways to justice

🧠 Summary

Ray and Jonathan dive headfirst into the complexities of being Jewish and opposing Zionism. Jonathan explains that while Judaism is rooted in moral commandments like “thou shalt not kill,” Zionism, as it’s manifested in Israel’s policies, contradicts those values. Growing up Orthodox and visiting Israel multiple times—including on the Birthright program—Randall once bought into the nationalist narrative. But through study, travel, and unlearning, he began to speak out against Israel’s treatment of Palestinians.

Since October 7th, the backlash has intensified. Jonathan shares how his brother cut him off, his comedy gigs have been canceled, and he’s received hate not only from Zionists but also from pro-Palestinian voices skeptical of his intentions. Despite it all, he continues to use social media and stage time to advocate for truth, even comparing modern Israeli worship to the biblical Golden Calf—misguided idolatry.

The episode also unpacks media bias, Netanyahu’s controversial leadership, settler violence in the West Bank, and why “Never Again” must apply to all people—not just Jews. Jonathan’s courage resonates deeply, particularly because it comes from within the community so often associated with unwavering support for Israel.

🔎 Practical Tips

• Question what you’ve been taught—truth often requires unlearning
• Speak out even when it's inconvenient or dangerous; courage inspires change
• Focus on human rights over political loyalty or cultural conditioning

📚 Research Spotlight

The documentary Israelism, which features Jewish Americans reckoning with their indoctrination about Israel, provides critical context to Randall’s journey. It highlights a generational shift in how young Jews view Zionism and human rights.

❓FAQ

Q: Why is it significant that Jonathan Randall is Jewish and speaking out against Israel?
A: His voice challenges the common conflation of Judaism with Zionism, giving credibility to critiques of Israeli policy and inspiring other Jewish people to think critically about their inherited beliefs.

⏱️ Chapters & Timestamps

• 00:00 – Introduction: Why This Episode Matters
• 01:47 – Who Is Jonathan Randall?
• 02:05 – Judaism vs. Zionism Explained
• 03:17 – Jonathan’s Journey to Advocacy
• 05:18 – Indoctrination in Orthodox Upbringing
• 07:24 – Emotional Impact of Watching Gaza
• 10:41 – Family Fallout: Losing His Brother & Father
• 14:44 – Backlash in Comedy & Cancelled Gigs
• 21:22 – Highlighting Israelism & Jewish Movements
• 25:44 – Protest Experiences in NYC
• 28:02 – West Bank Realities & Settler Violence
• 33:46 – Netanyahu’s Role & Propaganda
• 37:26 – Genocide Debate & Humanitarian Lens
• 40:34 – Persona Non Grata? Can He Visit Israel?
• 46:36 – Performing Through Censorship & Resistance
• 48:06 – Shoutout to Dave Smith & Pro-Freedom Voices

🧭 Final Thought

When identity meets integrity, change becomes possible. Jonathan Randall is proof that speaking truth—even at personal cost—can inspire a ripple effect of awakening.

🔗 Social & Links

Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/deepshallowdive
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/deepshallowdive
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@deepshallowdive
Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@raydoustdar
Follow us on X: https://x.com/deepshallowdive
Join us on Threads: https://www.threads.com/@deepshallowdive
Subscribe on Substack: https://deepshallowdive.substack.com/

Ray Doustdar

Adding a new chapter to his diverse career, Ray now steps into the world of literature as an author, presenting his debut work, 'Deep Shallow Dive into You.' This book is a testament to his commitment to fostering personal growth and self-awareness.

Ray's venture into authorship extends his passion for meaningful communication and impact into writing, offering readers a transformative journey designed to cultivate a more authentic relationship with themselves.

Ray aims to connect with readers profoundly through his writing, sharing insights and strategies to help them uncover their true selves and live with unwavering authenticity and intention.

https://www.deepshallowdive.com