Guest #63 | Caroline Stout. Self-Awareness.
She grew up in a mega-church where patriotism was gospel, got recruited by Turning Point USA at 16, and once believed liberalism was a sin. But somewhere between CPAC stages and MAGA rallies, Caroline Stout started asking dangerous questions. This episode is about what happens when you finally trust your gut over your group—and the fallout that follows.
🎙️ Leaving the Cult of Conservatism | Caroline Stout on Faith, Politics & the Power of Rethinking
What happens when a lifelong conservative dares to think for herself? Caroline Stout’s journey from Turning Point USA insider to progressive advocate is a wake-up call for anyone questioning the political and religious dogmas they were raised in.
Episode Overview
In Episode #367, Ray Doustdar sits down with Caroline Stout, a former conservative activist turned outspoken progressive, to unpack how deeply intertwined religion and right-wing politics are—and how dangerous that fusion has become. From her early days in a Southern Baptist mega-church to interning at Turning Point USA and brushing shoulders with Fox News personalities, Caroline had a front-row seat to the making of the conservative movement. But she also saw the cracks.
This is more than a political conversion story. It’s a lesson in critical thinking, emotional courage, and reclaiming your personal agency.
🎯 Key Takeaways
• The conservative movement offers identity before ideology—and that's the hook
• Turning Point USA targets teens to create loyal mouthpieces, not thinkers
• Evangelical Christianity often fuses faith with Republican dogma—by design
• Doubting your politics often means doubting your religion, and that’s by design too
• Leaving the movement comes with backlash—but also clarity and community
🧠 Summary
Caroline Stout’s story begins in a Baptist mega-church in Houston, complete with aerialist-filled Christmas pageants and political sermons. Faith and patriotism weren’t just complementary—they were fused. At 16, she dove headfirst into Republican politics, working on Governor Greg Abbott’s campaign and starting a Young Republicans club in high school.
But it was Turning Point USA that gave her a sense of power, community, and purpose. They told her conservatism was about fiscal responsibility and limited government—and conveniently left out the bigotry and dogma. It wasn’t until Trump’s rise in 2015-2016, and the vitriolic culture it ushered in, that Caroline started to question what she was actually standing for.
The unraveling began quietly. Writing articles meant to stoke fear. Watching colleagues lean into hate. Realizing that if she could be this easily manipulated, so could millions of others. The hardest part? Questioning her religious beliefs, which were welded to her politics. Leaving meant being seen as a heretic by her own family.
But Caroline doesn’t regret it. Today, she’s fighting fascism from the front lines of a congressional campaign in Texas, determined to create space for others walking away from the cult of conservative conformity.
🔎 Practical Tips
• If something feels off in your beliefs—follow that thread
• Separate your identity from your political affiliations
• Seek out diverse voices, especially those who’ve left the systems you're in
• Allow yourself to doubt without shame—faith and ideology should withstand scrutiny
• Remember: You’re allowed to change your mind. That’s called growth
📚 Research Spotlight
According to a 2023 Pew Research study, over 40% of U.S. adults under 30 identify as politically independent, and many cite disillusionment with both parties—especially the GOP's embrace of Christian nationalism—as a key reason.
❓FAQ
Why did Caroline leave Turning Point USA?
Because she realized the organization was built more on fear and manipulation than true conservative values—and that it weaponized identity to silence dissent.
Was she ever “canceled” by her former peers?
Not officially, but she received death threats and rejection from both her political and familial circles after speaking out.
How did her faith shift during this journey?
She temporarily walked away from Christianity but later returned, this time with a more personal, critically examined belief system.
What does she hope others take away from her story?
That you're not alone in questioning everything—and you have permission to change.
⏱️ Chapters & Timestamps
00:15 – Discovering Caroline through Instagram
01:56 – Growing up Baptist in Texas
06:00 – Christianity and unwavering support for Israel
08:09 – How she got involved with Turning Point USA
11:00 – The early appeal of limited government
16:53 – CPAC, identity-building, and conservative culture
23:15 – The rise of Trump and the ideological split
26:12 – Realizing media narratives were skewed
29:04 – Wrestling with faith and politics
33:34 – The internal crisis of belief
36:01 – Taking responsibility and finding new community
41:27 – Her mission today: fight fascism and promote critical thinking
45:12 – Strained family ties and moving forward
🧭 Final Thought
You don’t owe loyalty to a lie—especially one dressed up as faith or patriotism. Choose truth, even when it costs you.
🔗 Social & Links
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/deepshallowdive
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/deepshallowdive
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@deepshallowdive
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@raydoustdar
X/Twitter: https://x.com/deepshallowdive
Threads: https://www.threads.com/@deepshallowdive
Substack: https://deepshallowdive.substack.com/
